8 Comments
User's avatar
Sean Byrnes's avatar

You're doing it again, taking one example and extrapolating WAY too far. The IHP was no different than most liberal arts degrees! Even I had to take religion, classics, even learn new sports to graduate. A better question is why programs like this don't result in religious conversions elsewhere and this one particular one did.

You also vilify the administration, but there isn't a lot of detail anywhere about what really happened. There are a lot of reasons programs like that are ended. Meanwhile, they are alive and well at a ton of liberal arts colleges even today!

Adam Singer's avatar

You’re right that many liberal arts programs include classics, religion, and the arts, but the Integrated Humanities Program (IHP) at KU was unusual even among liberal arts programs in how immersive and intense it was. Students lived together, read, memorized, sang, and stargazed almost as a form of communal formation, not just coursework. There are contemporary accounts and alumni testimonies noting that the program profoundly affected students’ worldview and, in some cases, led to religious conversions.

As for the administration, the historical record is sparse—officially, the program was ended due to “curricular restructuring” and budget decisions. But multiple sources note that the intensity of its moral and aesthetic formation raised eyebrows in ways other programs didn’t. Programs with a standard course load or occasional classics seminar rarely produce the same kind of transformation precisely because they don’t immerse students so fully. It's also possible all this is just wholly impractical to replicate, but I rather like the story as it does illustrate something interesting.

Sean Byrnes's avatar

You're still describing the liberal arts college experience! Students live together in dorms, and in many cases there are specific shared-interest houses. The communal aspect of college is a big reason why college students find the experience transforming.

I still don't see much evidence that the IHP produced a transformation based on the nature of the program. It's much more likely that at a school like KU there were specific dynamics between catholic students and non-catholic students. We have plenty of examples of how students convert when they are in a small, close-knit community of existing religious believers.

Adam Singer's avatar

This book might be worth a read (I haven't read yet but now want to - had just read several pieces online about it). If this were just normal college community dynamics I doubt anyone would still be talking about it. https://www.amazon.com/Senior-Restoration-Realism-Father-Francis/dp/0997314001

Sean Byrnes's avatar

People are talking about because religion is in decline and those in religion want evidence that it's not just the failing appeal of religion. This story makes the case that many more people would become religious if only the establishment wasn't stopping them. It's a fairytale and people love fairytales.

That book is a great example, and there others on IHP by religious figures as well.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jan 28
Comment removed
Adam Singer's avatar

Yes, also "show don't tell" is a key principle in marketing for a reason