One could even say that more joy came from booking a trip or a night out when it was done via phone with a person BEFORE we booked online. We might meet that person or at least have likely had one of the most highly sought out experiences that are diminishing in our "online" lives - a quality personal interaction with another person.
Everyone acts today as if strangers are too challenging to deal with (look at dating). The reality is that more joy comes from interactions with other people than anywhere else in life.
Although partly the joy of working with a travel agent - I remember them, too - is that flights were so much cheaper then. I'll never forget the travel agent on my college campus who got me a flight home for the holidays for $90! She was a genius - today I book all of my travel for spring/summer or fall/holidays in one sitting each. I feel like I'm getting mugged by my airline - and lectured in bright red ink for not booking at the more expensive level - so I compartmentalize the trauma and then just walk away.... Thanks for another excellent post - as always!
I think that the AI companies have yet to find the killer app for the general public, so they're casting about for ideas that only save minimal amounts of time and effort.
Compare to the Internet. It allowed us to do things we simply couldn't before that. It expanded our lives. AI does some of that professionally, but few of the personal use cases amount to much, yet.
Several good points, but your advice that I constantly come back to is how much of our current digital malaise is reduced or totally removed by simply using a desktop computer and saving your phone for phone calls and texts.
I agree with more of this than I expected to. Wanting to be the one who decides the details is the part I'd hold onto. For me the answer has been to let it carry the busywork and keep the decisions, because the deciding is where the living happens.
There's nothing new under the sun. Even looking back to something like learning math in high school, I came to a similar realization. Unless you're entering a math-specific field, then there technically isn't a "reason" to learn math when a calculator is faster and more capable. However, as I always saw it, the point wasn't to get really good at math, but to learn and practice the unique ways math causes you to think, reason, and problem solve. Perhaps this doesn't apply quite as cleanly to more menial tasks like making dinner reservations, but it seems a lot of tech guys (especially ones who push AI creative tools), don't understand that a lot of life experiences are more about the process than the final result.
I remember being able to take long walks with just my thoughts. No walkman, no phone. I remember payphones. I remember being enthralled by seeing a film at the theater. Seeing it more than once, because that's all you got. I remember talking to my friends about the shows we watched. They were all the same shows, because Happy Days was all that was on after dinner on a weeknight. Remember radio? Life was a shared experience, with people you might not know, but who lived in the same place at the same time. Shopped in the same grocery stores for the same products. We had to try harder. Everything took more effort and more time, and we were better for it
So, first, I personally take offense about the generalization about the tech industry. You know that's not true, and making those kinds of sweeping statements isn't helpful. You are in the tech industry as well, which makes it every worse! Hypocrisy is the worst kind of faux righteousness.
Second, AI is not trained by tech people for tech people. It's trained on the grand sum of all human writing and content, which makes it the average of everything we've ever done. It turns out that is pretty good! But that's also why training doesn't produce better and better models anymore.
Yes, it's true that some of the model providers decide to adjust the inputs/outputs to these models but that goes both ways. Elon wants grok to respond certain ways to questions where he doesn't like the answer the model finds on its own, so they change it. That's not training, that's editorial.
Third, almost no one enjoys booking flights or reservations. If you travel frequently, it's a nightmare! We've been trying to automate those kinds of miserable tasks since the earliest days of travel when travel agents used to do it for you. That's not ceding agency, it's removing meaningless friction.
Finally, you are confusing agency with activity. All of these tasks don't make up agency, they make up work that needs to be done. You have the same amount of agency if you decide to do the work yourself or hire someone to do it or use AI. Agency comes from the decision about what you want to do, not in the actual doing of it.
No personal offense meant here, but do note the top companies in the space are declaring their product "conscious" and that they "could end the species" - I think it's never been more appropriate time for people in our own sector to provide some sober feedback to the mania we clearly reside within. Still, I wouldn't short the market :)
If by "top companies in the space" you mean Anthropic? That's far from most people in tech.
I agree that they continue to spout nonsense, but I also don't think they are representative of the industry. In fact, the industry seems to find what they are saying pretty ridiculous.
Anthropic and Open AI have a bunch of ...let's say, interesting people there, but also the broader push of AI into every product and process and by many management teams is something to note (in many cases not even tied to something that makes sense). Every other ad we see is AI, every earnings call mentions AI, etc etc. Interestingly I'm much more okay with being pushed AI for work tasks (because sure, if that's what people want they're paying me to do a job) but for personal life since we have some choice I think through much deeper what I'm willing to outsource. Here's a good visualization that illustrates the decision well I saw the other day -> https://www.kulikowski.me/blog/the-spectrum-of-agentic-interactions
People selling their own products is far from a mania!
And I don't see much different here from the advent of the smartphone. I went to a talk where the CTO of Nokia called the iPhone a "nice proof of concept", which then took over the world. AI is doing that too, and it's not because tech companies are advertising.
I agree that it's infantilizing, but I also get it on a certain level. This is probably one of the most psychologically exhausting times ever to live in given all the bullshit we all have to deal with day in and day out thanks to the tech we're often forced to use. If there's something that helps cut down on the amount of bullshit you have to wade through, I can kinda understand why some people would find that appealing.
One could even say that more joy came from booking a trip or a night out when it was done via phone with a person BEFORE we booked online. We might meet that person or at least have likely had one of the most highly sought out experiences that are diminishing in our "online" lives - a quality personal interaction with another person.
Everyone acts today as if strangers are too challenging to deal with (look at dating). The reality is that more joy comes from interactions with other people than anywhere else in life.
really well put
Although partly the joy of working with a travel agent - I remember them, too - is that flights were so much cheaper then. I'll never forget the travel agent on my college campus who got me a flight home for the holidays for $90! She was a genius - today I book all of my travel for spring/summer or fall/holidays in one sitting each. I feel like I'm getting mugged by my airline - and lectured in bright red ink for not booking at the more expensive level - so I compartmentalize the trauma and then just walk away.... Thanks for another excellent post - as always!
I think that the AI companies have yet to find the killer app for the general public, so they're casting about for ideas that only save minimal amounts of time and effort.
Compare to the Internet. It allowed us to do things we simply couldn't before that. It expanded our lives. AI does some of that professionally, but few of the personal use cases amount to much, yet.
"Perhaps some percentage of the population doesn’t really want to do *anything*"
I think you have nailed it here.
Several good points, but your advice that I constantly come back to is how much of our current digital malaise is reduced or totally removed by simply using a desktop computer and saving your phone for phone calls and texts.
I agree with more of this than I expected to. Wanting to be the one who decides the details is the part I'd hold onto. For me the answer has been to let it carry the busywork and keep the decisions, because the deciding is where the living happens.
Its nice that all of the AI craziness is pretty concentrated in a small area. They just yell very loud about everything.
The rest of the actual real world continues to be pretty awesome.
AI is computer magic to build personal and work projects + crunching large data sets and finding patterns.
Giving it any decision making, general thinking, or access to personal info / accounts is pure madness. You are screwing your future self doing it.
There's nothing new under the sun. Even looking back to something like learning math in high school, I came to a similar realization. Unless you're entering a math-specific field, then there technically isn't a "reason" to learn math when a calculator is faster and more capable. However, as I always saw it, the point wasn't to get really good at math, but to learn and practice the unique ways math causes you to think, reason, and problem solve. Perhaps this doesn't apply quite as cleanly to more menial tasks like making dinner reservations, but it seems a lot of tech guys (especially ones who push AI creative tools), don't understand that a lot of life experiences are more about the process than the final result.
Never in my wildest dreams did I think that I would miss the '80s.
90s were great too, our best decade IMO (not old enough to remember the 80s much but I was there)
I remember being able to take long walks with just my thoughts. No walkman, no phone. I remember payphones. I remember being enthralled by seeing a film at the theater. Seeing it more than once, because that's all you got. I remember talking to my friends about the shows we watched. They were all the same shows, because Happy Days was all that was on after dinner on a weeknight. Remember radio? Life was a shared experience, with people you might not know, but who lived in the same place at the same time. Shopped in the same grocery stores for the same products. We had to try harder. Everything took more effort and more time, and we were better for it
So, first, I personally take offense about the generalization about the tech industry. You know that's not true, and making those kinds of sweeping statements isn't helpful. You are in the tech industry as well, which makes it every worse! Hypocrisy is the worst kind of faux righteousness.
Second, AI is not trained by tech people for tech people. It's trained on the grand sum of all human writing and content, which makes it the average of everything we've ever done. It turns out that is pretty good! But that's also why training doesn't produce better and better models anymore.
Yes, it's true that some of the model providers decide to adjust the inputs/outputs to these models but that goes both ways. Elon wants grok to respond certain ways to questions where he doesn't like the answer the model finds on its own, so they change it. That's not training, that's editorial.
Third, almost no one enjoys booking flights or reservations. If you travel frequently, it's a nightmare! We've been trying to automate those kinds of miserable tasks since the earliest days of travel when travel agents used to do it for you. That's not ceding agency, it's removing meaningless friction.
Finally, you are confusing agency with activity. All of these tasks don't make up agency, they make up work that needs to be done. You have the same amount of agency if you decide to do the work yourself or hire someone to do it or use AI. Agency comes from the decision about what you want to do, not in the actual doing of it.
No personal offense meant here, but do note the top companies in the space are declaring their product "conscious" and that they "could end the species" - I think it's never been more appropriate time for people in our own sector to provide some sober feedback to the mania we clearly reside within. Still, I wouldn't short the market :)
If by "top companies in the space" you mean Anthropic? That's far from most people in tech.
I agree that they continue to spout nonsense, but I also don't think they are representative of the industry. In fact, the industry seems to find what they are saying pretty ridiculous.
Anthropic and Open AI have a bunch of ...let's say, interesting people there, but also the broader push of AI into every product and process and by many management teams is something to note (in many cases not even tied to something that makes sense). Every other ad we see is AI, every earnings call mentions AI, etc etc. Interestingly I'm much more okay with being pushed AI for work tasks (because sure, if that's what people want they're paying me to do a job) but for personal life since we have some choice I think through much deeper what I'm willing to outsource. Here's a good visualization that illustrates the decision well I saw the other day -> https://www.kulikowski.me/blog/the-spectrum-of-agentic-interactions
People selling their own products is far from a mania!
And I don't see much different here from the advent of the smartphone. I went to a talk where the CTO of Nokia called the iPhone a "nice proof of concept", which then took over the world. AI is doing that too, and it's not because tech companies are advertising.
I agree that it's infantilizing, but I also get it on a certain level. This is probably one of the most psychologically exhausting times ever to live in given all the bullshit we all have to deal with day in and day out thanks to the tech we're often forced to use. If there's something that helps cut down on the amount of bullshit you have to wade through, I can kinda understand why some people would find that appealing.